In Her
Arms, a Nation:
The
Calculated Escape of Marie de Guise and Mary, Queen of Scots
On
23 July 1543, under cover of dusk, a small but loyal party arrived at
Linlithgow Palace with a dangerous mission: to help Marie de Guise and her
infant daughter, Mary, Queen of Scots, escape the tightening grip of political
unrest. The palace, once a cradle of royal splendor, had become a gilded cage
watched closely by both supposed allies and bitter enemies. At just nine months
old, Mary was already a prize in a perilous game of power, her crown contested
by rival factions and her future eyed by foreign powers, most notably England
and France. Marie, fiercely protective and politically astute, knew she could
no longer trust the delicate balance holding her daughter’s life in place.
Their destination was Stirling Castle, an imposing fortress rising above the
River Forth, and a place where, for now, the crown could rest in safer hands.
The journey would be swift, secret, and shadowed by danger- for in a realm torn
by ambition, betrayal was never far behind.
King James V of Scotland died on 14
December 1542, broken in both body and spirit after a military defeat at Solway
Moss. His death left the throne to his only surviving legitimate child, Mary, a
fragile infant just six days old. Her unexpected succession plunged Scotland
into a political crisis. As the realm reeled from the shock, the question of
who would govern on behalf of the infant queen sparked immediate and intense
rivalries: two powerful and ideologically opposed figures emerged as contenders
for the regency: James Hamilton, Earl of Arran, a Protestant nobleman with
royal blood and a claim to the throne himself; and Cardinal David Beaton, the
Catholic Archbishop of St. Andrews, who insisted he carry out the late king’s
dying wish to appoint him protector of the realm. Their conflict was not merely
personal, it represented the deepening religious and political fractures in
Scotland, with one eye turned toward reform and alliance with Protestant
England, and the other clinging to traditional ties with the Catholic Church
and France. The fate of the infant queen, and the very soul of Scotland, hung
in the balance.
Ultimately, the Protestant cause
prevailed…for a time. James Hamilton, Earl of Arran, was declared Governor and
Protector of Scotland, placing the infant queen under his wardship and giving
the Protestant faction a temporary upper hand. Cardinal David Beaton, defeated
politically, was arrested and placed under house arrest, his ambitions checked
but not extinguished. With Beaton sidelined, Arran came under increasing
pressure from King Henry VIII of England, who saw an opportunity to bring the
Scottish crown into closer alliance, and eventual subjugation, through
marriage.
In July 1543, Arran agreed to the
Treaty of Greenwich, a pair of accords that promised peace between the two
kingdoms and, most significantly, the betrothal of the infant Queen Mary to
Henry’s only legitimate son, Prince Edward. The treaty stipulated that Mary
would be sent to England at the age of ten to be raised as Edward’s future
queen- a union that, in Henry’s eyes, would finally unite the crowns of England
and Scotland under Tudor control. But the treaty, far from securing peace,
planted the seeds of future rebellion. Many in Scotland viewed it as a betrayal
of national sovereignty, and the notion of sending their queen to be raised in
a foreign and Protestant court, soon sparked a fierce and dangerous backlash.
This vision of an Anglo-Scottish
union was met with outrage across much of Scotland, especially among those
fiercely loyal to the centuries-old Auld Alliance with France. To many Catholic
nobles and traditionalists, the Treaty of Greenwich was not a diplomatic
triumph but a dangerous surrender- an attempt to hand over their sovereign
child to a heretic king who had broken from Rome and executed his own queens.
The thought of young Mary being raised in the English court, molded by
Protestant tutors and wed to a Tudor prince, was intolerable. Chief among the
opposition was Cardinal Beaton, who, though recently disgraced, still wielded
considerable influence within the Church and among the Catholic nobility. From
his confinement, Beaton conspired to free Queen Mary from what they viewed as
Protestant captivity. Their goal was clear- restore Catholic dominance, renew
ties with France, and ensure Scotland’s queen would remain beyond England’s
reach.
On 23 July 1543, Cardinal Beaton’s
allies made their move. Disguised as a rescue mission but charged with
political urgency, a band of loyal Catholic nobles arrived at Linlithgow Palace
under the pretense of protecting the queen. Tensions were high, and the risk
was immense. Protestant forces still held considerable influence, and any
misstep could spark open conflict. Just days later, under the cover of darkness
and with an armed escort, Marie de Guise and her infant daughter were smuggled
out of Linlithgow. Their destination was Stirling Castle, a bastion of royal
authority and a stronghold of the Catholic and pro-French faction. There, behind
thick stone walls and guarded by trusted allies, the infant Mary was finally
safe from English designs and Protestant ambition.
On 9 September 1543, in the chapel
of Stirling Castle, surrounded by bishops, nobles, and great officers of state,
Mary was formally crowned Queen of Scots. Though barely nine months old, she
wore a crown too large for her tiny head, symbolic of the immense weight
already placed upon her. Her coronation marked not only the beginning of her
reign but also the solidification of Catholic resistance to English pressure,
ensuring that Scotland’s future would remain fiercely contested.
The marriage treaty with England
was formally renounced in December 1543, just months after Mary’s coronation.
The fragile peace promised by the Treaty of Greenwich shattered as Scottish
nobles, led by Cardinal Beaton and supported by Queen Dowager Marie de Guise, rejected
the idea of binding their young queen to the son of England’s increasingly
aggressive and heretical king. Instead, Scotland looked once more to its oldest
and most trusted ally- France. In a bold reaffirmation of the Auld Alliance,
negotiations began to betroth Mary to Francis, the Dauphin of France and eldest
son of King Henry II. The match promised not only a royal union but also
military and financial support from France to counter English threats. In 1548,
the formal agreement was sealed, and five-year-old Mary was sent across the sea
to be raised in the glittering, sophisticated French court. This new alliance
bound Scotland and France together more tightly than ever, creating a Catholic
front against English Protestant expansion and reshaping the political
landscape of Western Europe. For Mary, it marked the beginning of a life that
would be shaped by foreign courts, powerful enemies, and the heavy expectations
of two kingdoms.
Cardinal David Beaton, the cunning
and forceful architect behind Mary’s escape from Linlithgow and a key figure in
the fight to keep Scotland allied with Catholic France, would not live to see
the young queen grow into her crown. In 1546, just three years after
orchestrating her flight to safety, Beaton met a brutal end. He was
assassinated in his own residence at St. Andrews Castle by a group of
Protestants who were outraged by his persecution of reformers and emboldened by
the rising tide of religious dissent. The immediate spark was the execution of
the Protestant preacher George Wishart, whom Beaton had condemned to death.
Days later, the conspirators stormed the castle, murdered the Cardinal, and
gruesomely displayed his body from a castle window as a message to those who
still clung to Catholic sympathy. His death sent shockwaves through Scotland,
deepening the divide between Protestant reformers and Catholic loyalists.
Beaton’s violent end was emblematic of the volatile religious and political
climate that had come to define Mary’s early life- a world where alliances
shifted like sand, power was seized by force, and even the most powerful men
were never truly safe.
©All
Things Tudors
